A Different Type of
After submitting a proposal on communication theory in biological systems to the NSF CDI competition, I stumbled across this neat drawing at the Museum of Modern Art in New York City. The title is Art and Nature, and the artist is Dudley Huppler. My interpretation? Science is crisp and neat. Nature is messy, composed of myriad inter-communicating actors. Yet and still, organization not only emerges but is uncannily repeatable despite the plethora of insults hurled at biological systems by the world. The nature of the implicit reliable code-to-structure/function transformation is one of the "big questions" in biology. (The ever-popular "Are we alone?" is another one -- next column over .)
A muse on whither structure/function by Nobelist Paul Nurse (pdf, local pdf) appears as a recent Nature "Horizons" article, Life, Logic and Information. The gist? We need to better understand information flow in biological systems -- which is exactly the topic of the proposal, though we're quite a bit more literal! (pun intended)
My partner in crime for this research is Saira Mian, a broadly knowledgeable computational biologist at Lawrence Berkeley National Labs. Our hope for this work is that there are coding, channel, network and rate distortion theorems in there somewhere -- perhaps even transcending biological systems since at heart everything is a network of inter-communicating actors.
9/1/2008: The proposal has been funded! Here are the reviews (with which I very much agree in almost all aspects). Thank you panelists whoever you are! Your encouragement (and suggestions/warnings) are duly noted and greatly appreciated. We vacillate between exhilaration and professional terror -- not a bad thing! Nothing ventured, nothing gained.
12/12/2009: Update -- a pivotal, but devilish problem is beating us about the head and face. However, we sense it's tiring out.
1/5/2010: NY Times profile of Mina Bissell and her work on the relationship between tissue architecture and cancer. Mina's work is what captivated me a few years back. Those genotypically malignant cells that stay quiet in normal tissue somehow know when they reside in a normal architecture and when they do not. This is an important (and new) communication problem if ever there was one.
5/3/2010: Mina Bissell elected to NAS!!!! Stockholm next!
7/29/2010: Here's an animation of (one aspect of) the molecular communication problem courtesy of Ruochen Song.
10/16/2010: Living things are so beautiful and precise that there must be a mathematics that describes them. Information theory is that mathematics. Tom Schneider, NIH
The following "summary slide" that ties together the above threads from biology to fundamental descriptions of the universe lies somewhere between profound and ludicrous, but it's so much fun I decided to post it here anyway:
Here's a fun talk I gave at ITA'13. Post-talk comments make me think it's time to write a summary/tutorial paper to incite the roiling masses of young communication theorists and reinvigorate (overthrow!) the technical status quo!
My Precious Students
(see also R. Yates' page)
Contentious Spectrum Management
Genetic Algorithms and Spectrum Sharing (DySpan'05)
Ultra-Blogging: I've been toying (since at least 2003 starting with an un-responded-to letter to William Safire of the NY Times and following up with an extremely weak talk I gave at Google in 2006) with the idea of doing research on the implications of the fact that soon, everything will be recorded and very little will be private. Think of Microsoft's My Life Bits but with the ability to share and search over the Internet. As a simple example of what's coming, the following candid photo was taken in Brazil at MWCN'01. I had no idea the photo existed until a Google search on my name turned it up (the site has since disappeared -- how fleeting fame! ). However, imagine if zillions of these sorts of candid moments (including audio) could be uploaded wirelessly, correlated, indexed and searched by a Super-Google over the web. Assuming symmetry of access and information accountability (with the possibility of information hiding by loggers -- or e-chroniclers), I'm not sure that loss of public privacy is such a bad idea. But it does give one pause to think that every public (and many an ostensibly private) moment could be subject to public scrutiny. Nonetheless, I see this not as "Big Brother" but more as "Everything In The Light Of Day" a la Rodney King where the watched can watch the watchers. Steve Mann at the University of Toronto has coined the rather neat term sousveillance for this sort of system (as opposed to SURveillance).
Public ServiceI recently submitted an NSF proposal which was declined, but I thought the reviews were especially helpful. As it is with these things, we often feel the reviewer might possibly have missed the point (see comment about characterizing moving foliage on trees being infeasible -- I AGREE, but if so, that still tells you something about the channel estimation problem ). However, objectively speaking, the reviewer might also be pointing out that I missed the point -- the practicality of the approach might be nil for most real-world systems -- but still offered helpful suggestions, I thought.
Anyone who wants to run with (or deride) the idea is
welcome to do so. I'm thinking I'll post all proposals and
subsequent reviews here as a public service (maybe
particularly helpful to new faculty if only as an example
of what not to
do if you want to get funded ).
Just TOO COOL!Here's one of my FAVORITE Nova segments on an up and coming ex-M.I.T. engineer named James McLurkin when he was a "kid". He's now a rising star at Rice. Yes, an engineer can truly have it all!
Caroline Angelo's cartoon
Project OZMA at 50 Workshop
Michael Crichton weighs in via The Andromeda Strain
(pp. 222-225, courtesy, Rich Howard)
National Radio Astronomy Observatory
NRAO Ozma at 50 Workshop
The SETI Institute
Mount a cheap directional antenna to a mobile platform, add ultrasonic sensors and student ingenuity and what to you get? Pure design delight! Here's the project report. Check it out in action on YouTube!
USEFUL FOR SESSION CHAIRS!!!
Spectrum Policy Outreach:
Innovative and Reliable Services in Unlicensed Spectrum.
A National Science Foundation collaboration with the Quello Center at
A must-read memoir by WINLAB's own Dick Frenkiel,
"Father of Cellular and Cordless"
National Medal of Technology (1994 Winner)
Cellular Dreams and Cordless Nightmares:
life at Bell Laboratories in interesting times
My Son, Evan Rose,
tried to become "The Future
of Night Life" with his startup Nite-Fly. He found that nightlife providers are a scary bunch -- most such businesses fail within a year or so, so they're not exactly forward looking. He (and we -- looking to retire early ) are much more hopeful about Evan's current business. He's essentially seeking to become a hitech headhunter who provides various companies with what they need -- smart employees. In the process he's become a rather good web developer! Check out e-cruit!
Former student, Randal Pinkett, founder of BCT Partners and the Donald Trump Season 4 Apprentice (Google Search) was absolutely spectacular as an undergraduate in our department -- I remember him most for never letting us see him sweat -- even when I made up an exam just for him (though I gave the exam to the whole class ). So, he's always been preternaturally graceful under pressure. Randal went on to an even more spectacular academic career (Rhodes Scholar, MBA and Ph.D. from M.I.T.) and was clearly the best candidate The Apprentice had ever seen. In fact, I found it puzzling how much hand wringing was done over which of the two final candidates to hire -- there really was no other choice. Perhaps they manufactured a bit of theater? Here's Randal's wikipedia page.
Brother" S. James
Gates, Jr., the John S. Toll Professor of Physics at UMD,
has been appointed to President Obama's Council of Advisors on
Science and Technology (PCAST for short). In December
2012 he was named
as a National Medal of Science winner. Jim was
actually a "big brother" (and a legend) for close to a generation
of students who came through MIT in the '70s and early '80s.
Jackson -- current president of RPI -- is another MIT legend
who's been appointed to the PCAST as well). Jim is an
amateur Einstein historian who focuses on Einstein's stance on
human rights. Jim also has ideas on diversity in the STEM
fields, espoused in a talk
at Rutgers in February 2011. Want more
information? Both Jim
have Wikipedia pages.
My "Brother" Emery Brown is a big deal professor in the Harvard/MIT program in Cambridge. We were antipodal undergrads (Emery was a Harvard brat while I was an MIT gnerd) and graduate students together. We also vied for lifer status (Emery won that one ). His area is anesthesiology as this delightful New York Times Profile shows. However, what many do not realize is that Emery's main research passion is something that knocks directly on the door of one of the biggest Big Questions there is: what is consciousness? Emery's experimental work considers how mental state relates to measurable electrical phenomena in the brain -- of rats, so there's no need to go out and buy helmets and tin foil hats ... yet. And as you might have already guessed, Em has a wikipedia page.
My "Little Brother" Todd Coleman is a newly minted Associate Professor with Tenure at UCSD in Bioengineering after successfully luring him from the corn (UIUC). He is a true academic star and not only scary smart, but scary driven and scary savvy. Here's a nice recent profile of Todd. His area is information theory applied to biological (mostly electrical) signals. Whether he wins a Nobel or creates a business empire only time will tell. Here's a recent Science paper of his that's causing somewhat of a rage in non-invasive bioelectrical signal sensing. I suspect a few more of these types of bombshells will be forthcoming soon. I'm delightedly proud (and somewhat in awe) of Todd.
Back to WINLAB home page
If you have questions, comments or other
suggestions please contact us here
or email your comments to email@example.com
by Nick Romanenko of Rutgers